Skip to main content

1.3 Come With the Same Energy: A Lodging for The Night by Robert Louis Stevenson (1877)

To put it mildly, my knowledge of turn of the twentieth century literature is limited. When I came across “A Lodging For the Night” it was the first time reading this collection I recognized the author’s name. Robert Louis Stevenson, best known for Treasure Island and The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde, is the first non-American author and his story is the least interested in the codependent logics of colonialism and “the frontier.”
Cover page for a very limited run in 1900

Where Davis plotted an anti colonial tale about communication as a form of imperialism, and where White focused on the limits and spaces beyond “the frontier,” Stevenson’s “A Lodging for the Night” hones in on time and place. We begin at the beginning: “It was late in November, 1456. The snow fell over Paris with rigorous, relentless persistency…” What follows is a speculative account of what happened to the modern French poet François Villon, who disappeared sometime in 1463. Stevenson’s account is filled with grim details about the forbidding landscape of a snowed-out, almost apocalyptic Paris. But this isn’t a “man against the elements of nature” narrative. Snow offers a way to cover up past tracks just as much as it quietly but violently smothers those who might venture out and unprepared.

Opening in a small home near the “cemetery of St. John,” Stevenson follows Villon as he leaves the house after the rogue Montigny murders a man in the midst of a game. Pilfering the money that remains on his body, Montigny gives some to everyone present. Each man accepts it and thus accepts the murder. All are accountable. No one can say a word.
As the men plan to disperse, Villon is pick-pocketed. Unaware, he continues to search Paris for shelter during this wretchedly cold evening. Shelter is difficult to come by—especially for a poet-thief with no money. 

The night is harsh. Villon stumbles through the city, walking into a dead woman in between being turned away by townsfolk uninterested in housing him. Eventually he is welcomed into the home of a lord. Like a buddy-cop movie of the 1980s or Billy Wilder’s The Apartment, difference becomes the basis for philosophical exchange.

Villon as a stamp

While the two first trade niceties, over time Villon refuses to hide his sociological views of the world and insults the man by embracing his own status as a ruffian. For Villon, his desire to steal is driven by the poor conditions he grew up around. With an interrogative explanation he chides the older man: “do you really fancy that I steal for pleasure? I hate stealing, like any other piece of work or of danger. My teeth chatter when I see a gallows. But I must eat, I must drink, I must mix in society of some sort. What the devil! Man is not a solitary animal…” Stealing is equated with labor as the poet threads together an act of theft, an act of danger and an act of work. He relates to all three the same way.

“The thief and the lord” sounds like a title to one of those popular social psychology books and Stevenson plays out some of the questions that Malcolm Gladwell might be interested in. This central conversation orbits around Villon’s refusal to denigrate his identity. The old man, the Lord of Brisetout, is confounded by such views and the moral relativism that follows. Though the two never come to blows, Villon is ultimately cast out, and the tale ends as the next dawn breaks. With this new day the historical bard heads out and continues his life, having never given an argumentative inch.

Stevenson’s tale is fundamentally concerned with the multiple valences of social and economic class. It is also about identity. Villon could have hidden his opinions, he could have subsumed his identity for the sake of sanctuary. I take Stevenson here to be making a point about the importance of living out one’s beliefs. As folks say now, live your truth. Come with the same energy, no matter the circumstance.

Robert Louis Stevenson

Rather than castigating his characters Stevenson explores the logic of their ideological positions. He unwinds the chains of thought that inform how individuals move through life, explaining “There is only one limit to [a thief’s] fortune—that of time; and a spendthrift with only a few crowns is the Emperor of Rome until they are spent.” Observational detail serves a sort dialectic purpose that gestures at class analysis. In these details Stevenson shapes the plot’s ambiguous conclusion.

Of all the stories read so far this is perhaps the most philosophical. Stevenson appears interested in the relationship between metaphysical questions of being and sociological questions of caste. This brief speculative experiment succeeds because of his emphasis on quotidian description. Early in the story Stevenson describes Villon’s visage writing, “the wolf and pig struggled together in his face.” This is not some generalizing moral cover. Rather than a turn to physiognomy-as-indicator-of-criminality, Stevenson includes this analogy as one element in the fabric of this depiction of France. This face is as much a part of the city as the architecture of the cemetery.

And though this story recounts a night in the haze of murder, Stevenson’s tale raises more questions than it ever deigns to answer.

You can read “A Lodging for the Night,” part of Stevenson’s New Arabian Nights collection, at Project Gutenberg: http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/839

You can listen to “A Lodging for The Night” at Librivox: https://librivox.org/short-story-collection-vol-055-by-various/ 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2.7 It Might All Be Redrawn: To Love and To Honor by Octavus Roy Cohen (1925)

Things were always going to be different when they looked back. It was not always clear how but in the midst of twenty-five years, life had changed and the friendship built between George Potter but his attorney continued to grow. Though the attorney worried about George’s social life, he was excited to participate in the 25 th anniversary celebration of Mr. and Mrs. Potter. He’d been there for their wedding and he would be there for this fete. George had set everything up—the event would look exactly as the wedding had a quarter of a century ago. George was still a bit romantic and his longing for the past coincided with his eagerness for the future. That wedding is the central conceit of Octavus Roy Cohen’s 3 page story "To Love and to Honor." A clinic in the economy of storytelling, the romantic engagements of George Potter are relayed through his friend and attorney who fills in all the details we need to know, and some that we don’t (George had a "very excelle

2.8 Could It All Be So Simple?: The Mummy's Foot by Theophile Gautier (1840/1890) trans. Lafcadio Hearn

It was all a dream. Whether those words make you think of the wisdom of Biggie or the famous ending to that towering work of German Expressionism, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (Robert Wiene, 1920), I've always been fond of the multiple possibilities encased the phrase. For most of my teenage years those words were my obnoxious response to friends who feared that I might spoil a movie or television show they hadn't seen:  "See so then Tony Soprano walks out of the room and…" "Don't say anything I've got the episode taped!" "Oh, it's all a dream." Theophile Gautier (1811-1872) That the concluding twist of a story could be the revelation that it was only (or that it was all) a dream is, at this point, so rote and hackneyed my response was always met with a raised eyebrow and a guffaw (in the light way akin to "foh.") Played on to the point of absurdity, the twist can now seem somewhat surprising, as it does in

1.5 The Storing of Sweet Water: The Fourth Man by John Russell (1919)

The short stories described so far have all pivoted on a rupturing of expectations. From the plot twists that define O. Henry’s “Friends in San Rosario” and White’s “The Two-Gun Man” to the changing roles inhabited by Albert Gordon in Richard Harding Davis’ “The Reporter Who Made Himself King,” these tales have always taken a turn. John Russell’s “The Fourth Man” follows this trend, twisting faux-scientific expectations that have been predicated on political-social systems in the service of an anti-racist story. The question of honor among thieves also undergirds Russell’s narrative. Eventually adapted into a popular radio drama for CBS, “The Fourth Man” tracks the attempted escape of three white convicts from a prison in the Pacific island of New Caledonia. The award-winning Dr. Dubosc, the roguish Fenayrou and the many sobriquet’d killer “The Parrot” have broken out of the prison. The three men have taken a nameless black native of New Caledonia captive with the plan of using hi